Take That vs. The Smiths

Attribute	Take That	The Smiths
Genre	Pop	Indie rock
Origin	United Kingdom	United Kingdom
Active Years	1990-present	1982-1987
Members	Gary Barlow, Mark Owen, Howard Donald	Morrissey, Johnny Marr, Andy Rourke, Mike Joyce
Number of Albums	8	4

Background

Take That and The Smiths are two iconic British bands that have made a significant impact on the music industry. Take That was formed in Manchester in 1990 and consisted of members Gary Barlow, Howard Donald, Jason Orange, Mark Owen, and Robbie Williams. The Smiths, on the other hand, were formed in Manchester in 1982 and consisted of members Morrissey, Johnny Marr, Andy Rourke, and Mike Joyce. Both bands achieved great success during their respective careers, but they have very different styles and attributes that set them apart.

Musical Style

Take That is known for their catchy pop tunes and upbeat melodies. Their music often features harmonized vocals and danceable beats that appeal to a wide audience. The Smiths, on the other hand, are known for their melancholic lyrics and jangly guitar sound. Their music is often introspective and poetic, with themes of alienation and longing. While Take That's music is more mainstream and radio-friendly, The Smiths have a cult following and are considered pioneers of indie rock.

Lyrics

Take That's lyrics often focus on themes of love, relationships, and empowerment. Their songs are known for their positive messages and uplifting choruses that resonate with fans. In contrast, The Smiths' lyrics are more introspective and often explore darker themes such as loneliness, isolation, and disillusionment. Morrissey's poetic and sometimes controversial lyrics have earned him a reputation as one of the greatest lyricists in rock music.

Image and Persona

Take That has always been known for their clean-cut image and boy-next-door charm. The band members are often seen as heartthrobs and have a large female fan base. In contrast, The Smiths had a more alternative and rebellious image. Morrissey's androgynous style and outspoken personality set them apart from other bands of their time. The Smiths were seen as outsiders and misfits, which only added to their appeal among fans.

Success and Legacy

Take That achieved massive commercial success during the 1990s, with numerous hit singles and sold-out tours. The band's popularity waned after Robbie Williams left in 1995, but they made a successful comeback in the 2000s and continue to release new music to this day. The Smiths, on the other hand, had a relatively short career but left a lasting impact on the music industry. Their influence can be heard in the music of countless indie bands that followed in their footsteps.

Live Performances

Take That is known for their high-energy live performances that feature elaborate choreography and impressive stage production. The band members are skilled entertainers who know how to engage with their audience and put on a show. The Smiths, on the other hand, were known for their raw and intimate live performances. Morrissey's charismatic stage presence and Johnny Marr's virtuoso guitar playing made their concerts unforgettable experiences for fans.

Conclusion

While Take That and The Smiths may have different musical styles and personas, both bands have made a lasting impact on the music industry. Take That's catchy pop tunes and positive messages have earned them a loyal fan base, while The Smiths' introspective lyrics and unique sound have solidified their status as indie rock legends. Whether you prefer the upbeat melodies of Take That or the melancholic musings of The Smiths, there's no denying the talent and influence of these two iconic bands.