New Girl vs. That Girl

Attribute	New Girl	That Girl
Main Character	Jess Day	Ann Marie
Setting	Los Angeles	New York City
Genre	Comedy	Comedy
Number of Seasons	7	5
Release Year	2011	1966

Characters

New Girl and That Girl are both sitcoms that revolve around the lives of young women navigating their way through relationships, careers, and friendships. In New Girl, the main character Jess Day, played by Zooey Deschanel, is quirky, awkward, and endearing. She moves in with three single guys after a bad breakup and brings a fresh perspective to their lives. On the other hand, That Girl follows the story of Ann Marie, played by Marlo Thomas, a young aspiring actress living in New York City. Ann is independent, ambitious, and determined to make it in the entertainment industry.

Setting

New Girl is set in Los Angeles, where Jess and her roommates navigate the ups and downs of modern dating, friendships, and careers. The show features a mix of indoor and outdoor scenes, showcasing the vibrant and diverse city. That Girl, on the other hand, takes place in New York City during the 1960s, offering a glimpse into the bustling world of theater, fashion, and culture. The show captures the essence of the era with its iconic fashion and iconic landmarks.

Relationships

In New Girl, the relationships between the characters are central to the show's storyline. Jess forms close bonds with her roommates Nick, Schmidt, and Winston, as well as her best friend Cece. The romantic tension between Jess and Nick drives much of the plot, adding a layer of complexity to their friendship. That Girl, on the other hand, focuses on Ann's romantic relationships and her quest for love. Throughout the series, Ann navigates the dating scene in New York City, encountering various suitors and experiencing the highs and lows of romance.

Humor

New Girl is known for its quirky humor and witty dialogue, with each character bringing their own brand of comedy to the show. Jess's awkward antics, Schmidt's one-liners, and Winston's eccentric behavior all contribute to the show's comedic appeal. That Girl, on the other hand, relies more on situational humor and physical comedy to elicit laughs from the audience. Ann's misadventures in the entertainment industry and her interactions with the colorful characters she encounters provide plenty of comedic moments throughout the series.

Themes

Both New Girl and That Girl explore themes of friendship, love, and self-discovery. In New Girl, the characters navigate the complexities of modern relationships and the challenges of growing up in a fast-paced world. The show emphasizes the importance of friendship and support in overcoming life's obstacles. That Girl, on the other hand, focuses on Ann's journey of self-discovery and empowerment as she pursues her dreams in a male-dominated industry. The show highlights the struggles and triumphs of a young woman forging her own path in the world.

Legacy

New Girl has garnered a dedicated fan base and critical acclaim for its fresh take on the traditional sitcom format. The show's quirky humor, relatable characters, and heartfelt moments have made it a beloved favorite among viewers. That Girl, on the other hand, is considered a trailblazer in its own right, breaking new ground with its portrayal of a young, independent woman pursuing her dreams. The show's impact on popular culture and its influence on future female-led sitcoms cannot be understated.