Geno Smith vs. Matthew Stafford

Attribute	Geno Smith	Matthew Stafford
Age	31	33
College	West Virginia	Georgia
Height	6'3"	6'3"
Weight	221 lbs	220 lbs
Draft Year	2013	2009
Draft Round	2nd	1st
Current Team	Seattle Seahawks	Los Angeles Rams

Background

Geno Smith and Matthew Stafford are both NFL quarterbacks who have had varying degrees of success in their careers. Smith was drafted by the New York Jets in the second round of the 2013 NFL Draft, while Stafford was the first overall pick by the Detroit Lions in the 2009 NFL Draft. Both players have shown flashes of brilliance on the field, but also have had their fair share of struggles.

Arm Strength

One of the key attributes that sets Matthew Stafford apart from Geno Smith is his arm strength. Stafford is known for his ability to make deep throws and fit the ball into tight windows with velocity. His arm talent allows him to make all the throws necessary to succeed in the NFL, from quick outs to deep bombs down the field. On the other hand, Geno Smith has a solid arm, but it doesn't quite measure up to Stafford's in terms of sheer power and accuracy.

Decision Making

When it comes to decision making on the field, Matthew Stafford has the edge over Geno Smith. Stafford has shown the ability to read defenses quickly and make smart decisions with the football. He has a knack for finding the open receiver and avoiding costly turnovers. Geno Smith, on the other hand, has been criticized for his inconsistent decision making and tendency to force throws into coverage. This has led to a higher interception rate for Smith compared to Stafford.

Mobility

Both Geno Smith and Matthew Stafford possess above-average mobility for quarterbacks. Smith is known for his ability to extend plays with his legs and pick up yards on the ground when needed. He has shown the ability to escape pressure and make plays outside the pocket. Stafford, while not as mobile as Smith, is still capable of moving around in the pocket and making throws on the run. His mobility adds another dimension to his game and allows him to avoid sacks and keep plays alive.

Leadership

Leadership is another area where Matthew Stafford shines compared to Geno Smith. Stafford is known for his vocal presence in the locker room and on the field. He has earned the respect of his teammates with his work ethic and ability to rally the team in tough situations. Geno Smith, on the other hand, has faced criticism for his leadership skills in the past. Some have questioned his ability to command the huddle and inspire his teammates to perform at their best.

Experience

Matthew Stafford has a significant edge over Geno Smith when it comes to experience in the NFL. Stafford has been a starter in the league for over a decade and has seen just about everything the game has to offer. He has played in big games and high-pressure situations, which has helped him develop into a seasoned veteran. Geno Smith, on the other hand, has bounced around the league as a backup and has not had the same opportunities to gain valuable experience as a starter.

Conclusion

In conclusion, while both Geno Smith and Matthew Stafford have their strengths and weaknesses as NFL quarterbacks, it is clear that Stafford has the edge in several key areas. His arm strength, decision making, leadership, and experience all set him apart from Smith. However, Smith's mobility and potential for growth cannot be overlooked. Ultimately, both players have had their moments of success in the league, but Stafford's overall body of work and accomplishments give him the edge in this comparison.