Free Will vs. True Free Will

Attribute	Free Will	True Free Will
Definition	Ability to make choices without external constraints	Ability to make choices without any constraints, including internal ones
Determinism	May be influenced by external factors or past experiences	Not influenced by any factors, completely independent
Moral Responsibility	May be held accountable for choices made	Ultimate responsibility for all choices made
Compatibilism	Can coexist with determinism	Cannot coexist with determinism

Definition of Free Will

Free will is the ability to make choices that are not determined by factors outside of one's control. It is the belief that individuals have the power to make decisions based on their own desires, beliefs, and values. Free will is often seen as a fundamental aspect of human nature, allowing individuals to take responsibility for their actions and shape their own destinies.

Attributes of Free Will

One of the key attributes of free will is autonomy. Individuals with free will have the freedom to make choices that are not influenced by external forces. This autonomy allows individuals to act in accordance with their own values and beliefs, rather than being constrained by societal norms or expectations.

Another attribute of free will is agency. Individuals with free will have the ability to act independently and make decisions that have real consequences. This sense of agency gives individuals a sense of control over their lives and the ability to shape their own futures.

Free will is also characterized by responsibility. Individuals with free will are held accountable for their actions and the choices they make. This sense of responsibility is essential for maintaining a just and moral society, as it ensures that individuals are held responsible for the consequences of their actions.

Finally, free will is often associated with the concept of self-determination. Individuals with free will have the power to determine their own paths in life, rather than being subject to the whims of fate or external forces. This sense of self-determination is empowering, as it allows individuals to take control of their own destinies.

Definition of True Free Will

True free will goes beyond the basic concept of free will, suggesting that individuals have the ability to make choices that are not only free from external influences, but also free from internal biases, desires, and beliefs. True free will implies a level of freedom that is truly unconstrained, allowing individuals to make choices that are completely independent of any factors, internal or external.

Attributes of True Free Will

One of the key attributes of true free will is absolute autonomy. Individuals with true free will are completely free from any external influences, allowing them to make choices that are truly independent. This level of autonomy is rare, as most individuals are influenced to some degree by external factors such as societal norms, cultural beliefs, and personal relationships.

True free will also implies absolute agency. Individuals with true free will have the ability to act completely independently, without any internal biases or desires clouding their judgment. This level of agency is difficult to achieve, as most individuals are influenced to some degree by their own desires, beliefs, and emotions.

Another attribute of true free will is absolute responsibility. Individuals with true free will are held accountable for their actions in a way that is truly independent of any external factors. This level of responsibility is rare, as most individuals are influenced to some degree by external factors that may mitigate their accountability for their actions.

Finally, true free will is characterized by absolute self-determination. Individuals with true free will have the power to determine their own paths in life in a way that is completely unconstrained by any internal or external factors. This level of self-determination is rare, as most individuals are influenced to some degree by factors outside of their control.

Comparison of Free Will and True Free Will

While both free will and true free will share some common attributes, such as autonomy, agency, responsibility, and self-determination, the key difference lies in the level of freedom and independence that each concept implies. Free will allows individuals to make choices that are free from external influences, but may still be influenced by internal biases and desires. True free will, on the other hand, suggests a level of freedom that is truly unconstrained, allowing individuals to make choices that are completely independent of any factors, internal or external.

Another key difference between free will and true free will is the level of responsibility that each concept implies. While individuals with free will are held accountable for their actions and choices, individuals with true free will are held accountable in a way that is truly independent of any external factors. This level of responsibility is rare, as most individuals are influenced to some degree by external factors that may mitigate their accountability for their actions.

In conclusion, while free will and true free will both involve the ability to make choices that are not determined by external factors, true free will takes this concept a step further by suggesting that individuals have the ability to make choices that are completely free from any internal biases, desires, or beliefs. True free will implies a level of freedom that is truly unconstrained, allowing individuals to make choices that are completely independent of any factors, internal or external.