Frank Serpico vs. Jimmy Doyle

Attribute	Frank Serpico	Jimmy Doyle
Occupation	Police officer	Gangster
Personality	Brave, honest, principled	Ruthless, cunning, deceitful
Actions	Exposed corruption in the NYPD	Involved in criminal activities
Impact	Inspired reforms in law enforcement	Caused chaos and violence

Background

Frank Serpico and Jimmy Doyle are two fictional characters from popular crime dramas. Serpico is a character from the 1973 film "Serpico," based on the true story of an honest cop who exposed corruption within the New York City Police Department. Doyle, on the other hand, is a character from the 1990 film "State of Grace," a gritty crime thriller set in the Irish mob underworld of Hell's Kitchen, New York.

Personality

Frank Serpico is portrayed as a principled and idealistic police officer who refuses to take bribes or participate in corrupt activities. He is willing to risk his career and even his life to do what he believes is right. In contrast, Jimmy Doyle is a more morally ambiguous character who is torn between his loyalty to his criminal family and his desire to do the right thing. He struggles with his conscience and often finds himself in difficult situations where he must make tough choices.

Values

Frank Serpico values honesty, integrity, and justice above all else. He believes in upholding the law and serving the public good, even if it means going against his fellow officers. Serpico is willing to sacrifice his own well-being for the greater good and stands up for what he believes in, no matter the consequences. On the other hand, Jimmy Doyle values loyalty, family, and survival. He is willing to bend the rules and compromise his morals in order to protect his loved ones and stay alive in the dangerous world of organized crime.

Approach to Conflict

Frank Serpico confronts conflict head-on and is not afraid to challenge authority or expose wrongdoing. He is a whistleblower who is unafraid to speak truth to power and fight against corruption, even when it puts him in danger. Serpico is a lone wolf who operates outside the system and is willing to take on the establishment to make a difference. In contrast, Jimmy Doyle is more of a peacemaker who tries to avoid conflict and keep the peace within his criminal organization. He is a mediator who tries to find compromises and solutions to conflicts, rather than resorting to violence or confrontation.

Relationships

Frank Serpico has a strained relationship with his fellow officers, who see him as a troublemaker and a threat to their corrupt activities. He is a loner who struggles to trust others and form meaningful connections with his colleagues. Serpico's dedication to his principles often puts him at odds with those around him, leading to isolation and alienation. On the other hand, Jimmy Doyle has strong ties to his family and the criminal underworld. He is loyal to his friends and allies, willing to do whatever it takes to protect them and keep them safe. Doyle's relationships are based on loyalty and mutual respect, even if they are built on a foundation of crime and deception.

Conclusion

In conclusion, Frank Serpico and Jimmy Doyle are two complex characters with different approaches to morality, conflict, and relationships. Serpico is a principled whistleblower who fights against corruption and injustice, while Doyle is a conflicted criminal who struggles with his conscience and loyalty. Both characters face difficult choices and challenges that test their values and beliefs, ultimately shaping their destinies in profound ways.