Enchanted vs. Mary Poppins
What's the Difference?
Enchanted and Mary Poppins are both beloved films that blend live-action with animation to tell heartwarming stories. While Enchanted follows the journey of a fairytale princess who is transported to modern-day New York City, Mary Poppins tells the story of a magical nanny who brings joy and wonder to a British family. Both films feature strong female leads who use their magic to bring about positive change in the lives of those around them. Enchanted is a more modern take on the classic fairytale genre, while Mary Poppins is a timeless classic that has enchanted audiences for generations.
Comparison
| Attribute | Enchanted | Mary Poppins |
|---|---|---|
| Genre | Fantasy, Romance, Comedy | Fantasy, Musical, Family |
| Release Year | 2007 | 1964 |
| Setting | New York City, Andalasia | London |
| Lead Character | Giselle | Mary Poppins |
| Director | Kevin Lima | Robert Stevenson |
Further Detail
Plot
Enchanted follows the story of Giselle, a fairy-tale princess who is transported to modern-day New York City. She must navigate the unfamiliar world while trying to find her true love, Prince Edward. Mary Poppins, on the other hand, tells the tale of a magical nanny who comes to the Banks family to help them with their troubles. She uses her unique methods to teach the children valuable lessons and bring the family closer together.
Setting
Enchanted takes place in both the animated fairy-tale world of Andalasia and the bustling city of New York. The contrast between the two settings highlights the differences between Giselle's fantasy world and the reality of modern life. Mary Poppins is set in early 20th century London, capturing the charm and elegance of the time period. The quaint streets and iconic landmarks of London serve as the backdrop for the magical adventures of Mary Poppins and the Banks family.
Characters
In Enchanted, Giselle is a naive and optimistic princess who believes in true love and happily ever afters. She is contrasted with Robert, a cynical divorce lawyer who is skeptical of Giselle's fairy-tale beliefs. Mary Poppins features the titular character, a no-nonsense nanny with a touch of magic. She is joined by the mischievous Bert, who serves as her sidekick and friend. The Banks children, Jane and Michael, also play important roles in the story.
Music
Enchanted features several catchy musical numbers that pay homage to classic Disney princess songs. The songs are upbeat and whimsical, adding to the fairy-tale atmosphere of the film. Mary Poppins is known for its iconic songs, such as "Supercalifragilisticexpialidocious" and "Chim Chim Cher-ee." The music in Mary Poppins is a key element of the film, with the songs helping to move the story forward and convey important messages.
Themes
Enchanted explores themes of love, friendship, and the importance of staying true to oneself. Giselle learns to adapt to the modern world while still holding onto her beliefs in true love. Mary Poppins delves into themes of family, imagination, and the power of positivity. Mary Poppins teaches the Banks children valuable lessons through her magical adventures, helping them to see the world in a new light.
Visual Effects
Enchanted combines live-action with traditional animation, creating a visually stunning world that blends fantasy with reality. The transition between the animated fairy-tale world of Andalasia and the live-action setting of New York is seamless. Mary Poppins uses a combination of live-action and animation as well, with the iconic scenes of Mary Poppins and the children jumping into chalk drawings coming to life. The visual effects in both films add to the magical and whimsical feel of the stories.
Comparisons may contain inaccurate information about people, places, or facts. Please report any issues.