Disney Cinderella vs. Lily James Cinderella

Attribute	Disney Cinderella	Lily James Cinderella
Actress	Lily James	Lily James
Release Year	1950	2015
Director	Clyde Geronimi, Wilfred Jackson, Hamilton Luske	Kenneth Branagh
Setting	Fictional kingdom	Fictional kingdom
Costume Design	Traditional fairy tale style	Elaborate and detailed

Background

Disney's Cinderella, released in 1950, is a classic animated film that tells the story of a young woman who overcomes adversity with the help of her fairy godmother. Lily James' portrayal of Cinderella in the 2015 live-action adaptation brought a fresh perspective to the beloved character. Both versions of Cinderella have their own unique attributes that make them memorable to audiences.

Appearance

In the animated Disney film, Cinderella is depicted as a beautiful young woman with long, flowing blonde hair and a slim figure. She is often seen wearing a blue ball gown and glass slippers. Lily James' Cinderella, on the other hand, has a more natural look with brunette hair and a softer, more realistic appearance. Her costumes in the live-action film are elaborate and detailed, showcasing a more modern take on the classic character.

Personality

Disney's Cinderella is portrayed as kind, gentle, and patient, despite facing mistreatment from her stepmother and stepsisters. She remains optimistic and hopeful, believing that one day her dreams will come true. Lily James' Cinderella also embodies these qualities, but with a bit more depth and complexity. She is shown as a strong and independent woman who stands up for herself and others, making her a more relatable and empowering character.

Relationships

In the animated film, Cinderella's relationship with Prince Charming is based on love at first sight and a magical dance at the ball. Their connection is sweet and romantic, but lacks depth and development. In the live-action adaptation, Lily James' Cinderella and Prince Kit have a more nuanced relationship that is built on mutual respect, understanding, and shared values. Their love story feels more authentic and believable, making their happily ever after more satisfying.

Character Development

Disney's Cinderella undergoes a transformation from a mistreated servant to a princess with the help of her fairy godmother. Her character arc is focused on finding true love and happiness. Lily James' Cinderella, on the other hand, experiences growth and development through her own actions and choices. She learns to believe in herself and stand up for what she believes in, making her journey more empowering and inspiring.

Themes

Both versions of Cinderella explore themes of kindness, courage, and the power of believing in oneself. Disney's Cinderella emphasizes the importance of staying true to oneself and remaining hopeful in the face of adversity. Lily James' Cinderella delves deeper into themes of inner strength, resilience, and the ability to create one's own destiny. The live-action adaptation adds layers of complexity to the classic fairy tale, making it more relevant to modern audiences.

Conclusion

While Disney's Cinderella and Lily James' Cinderella both tell the timeless story of a young woman who overcomes obstacles to find her happily ever after, they each bring their own unique attributes to the character. Disney's Cinderella is a classic and beloved version that has stood the test of time, while Lily James' Cinderella offers a more modern and empowering take on the iconic princess. Both versions have their own strengths and appeal to audiences of all ages.