Devising vs. In Devising

Attribute	Devising	In Devising
Definition	Creating something new or original	Working within an existing framework or structure
Process	Collaborative and experimental	More structured and planned
Outcome	May be unpredictable and open-ended	Usually has a specific goal or purpose
Approach	Emphasizes creativity and innovation	Focuses on efficiency and effectiveness

Definition

Devising is a collaborative process in which a group of artists work together to create a piece of theatre from scratch. This can involve improvisation, experimentation, and exploration of different ideas and themes. In devising, the performers are actively involved in the creation of the piece, often contributing their own ideas and perspectives to the process.

In devising, on the other hand, refers to the act of creating something within a pre-existing framework or structure. This could involve adapting an existing text or script, or working within specific guidelines or constraints set by a director or playwright. In in devising, the performers may have less creative freedom compared to devising, as they are working within a predetermined framework.

Collaboration

Devising is a highly collaborative process, with all members of the ensemble working together to create the piece. This can involve brainstorming sessions, group discussions, and improvisation exercises to generate ideas and develop the material. Devising requires a high level of communication and trust among the performers, as they must be willing to share their ideas and work together towards a common goal.

In devising, on the other hand, may involve less collaboration among the performers, as they are working within a predetermined framework set by the director or playwright. While there may still be some opportunities for input and feedback, the performers may have less agency in shaping the final product compared to devising.

Creativity

Devising allows for a high degree of creativity and experimentation, as the performers are free to explore different ideas and approaches to creating the piece. This can lead to innovative and unique theatrical experiences that push the boundaries of traditional storytelling. Devising encourages performers to think outside the box and take risks in their creative choices.

In devising, on the other hand, may involve less room for creativity, as the performers are working within a predetermined framework or structure. While there may still be opportunities for creative expression, the performers may be more limited in their ability to experiment and take risks compared to devising.

Ownership

Devising allows performers to take ownership of the creative process, as they are actively involved in shaping the piece from the beginning. This can lead to a strong sense of ownership and investment in the final product, as the performers have contributed their own ideas and perspectives to the creation of the piece. Devising can be a deeply rewarding experience for performers, as they see their ideas come to life on stage.

In devising, on the other hand, may involve less ownership for the performers, as they are working within a framework set by someone else. While the performers may still have opportunities to contribute their ideas and perspectives, they may not feel as personally invested in the final product compared to devising.

Flexibility

Devising offers a high degree of flexibility, as the performers are free to explore different ideas and approaches to creating the piece. This can lead to a dynamic and ever-evolving creative process, as the performers are constantly experimenting and refining their ideas. Devising allows for a fluid and adaptable approach to creating theatre, as the performers can respond to new ideas and inspiration as they arise.

In devising, on the other hand, may involve less flexibility, as the performers are working within a predetermined framework or structure. While there may still be opportunities for input and feedback, the performers may be more constrained in their ability to adapt and change the material compared to devising.

Conclusion

Devising and in devising are two distinct approaches to creating theatre, each with its own strengths and limitations. Devising offers a highly collaborative and creative process that allows performers to take ownership of the material and explore new ideas and approaches. In devising, on the other hand, may involve less collaboration and creativity, as the performers are working within a predetermined framework set by someone else.

Ultimately, the choice between devising and in devising will depend on the goals and preferences of the artists involved. Some performers may thrive in a highly collaborative and creative environment, while others may prefer the structure and guidance provided by in devising. Both approaches have the potential to create powerful and engaging theatre, as long as the performers are willing to commit to the process and bring their own unique perspectives to the work.