Communal vs. Extended

Attribute	Communal	Extended
Definition	Shared by all members of a community	Enlarged or prolonged
Ownership	Shared ownership	Individual ownership
Relationships	Strong community relationships	Extended family relationships
Support system	Community support system	Extended family support system
Living arrangement	Living in a community setting	Living with extended family members

Definition

Communal living refers to a group of people living together and sharing common facilities and resources. This can include shared kitchens, bathrooms, and living spaces. Extended families, on the other hand, consist of multiple generations living together in the same household. This can include grandparents, parents, and children all living under one roof.

Size

Communal living arrangements tend to be smaller in size compared to extended families. Communal living spaces may consist of a few roommates or a small group of individuals sharing a house or apartment. Extended families, on the other hand, can be quite large, with multiple generations and extended relatives living together in one household.

Relationships

In communal living, relationships are often based on friendship and shared values. Roommates or housemates may choose to live together based on common interests or beliefs. In extended families, relationships are typically based on blood ties. Family members are connected through shared genetics and familial bonds that have been passed down through generations.

Support System

Communal living can provide a strong support system for its members. Roommates or housemates can rely on each other for emotional support, help with household chores, and companionship. Extended families also offer a support system, but it is often more ingrained in the family structure. Family members may provide financial assistance, childcare, and emotional support to one another.

Decision Making

In communal living, decisions are often made through consensus among the group. Roommates or housemates may hold regular meetings to discuss household matters and come to agreements together. In extended families, decision making may be more hierarchical, with older generations having more authority and influence over major decisions that affect the entire family.

Privacy

Privacy can be a concern in both communal living and extended families. In communal living, individuals may have less privacy due to shared living spaces and common areas. However, some communal living arrangements may offer private bedrooms or designated personal spaces. In extended families, privacy can also be limited, especially in larger households where multiple generations are living together.

Flexibility

Communal living arrangements can offer more flexibility in terms of living arrangements. Roommates or housemates may come and go as they please, and individuals can choose to leave the communal living situation if it no longer suits their needs. Extended families, on the other hand, may have more rigid structures and expectations, as family members are often expected to stay together and support one another through thick and thin.

Financial Considerations

Communal living can be a more affordable option for individuals looking to share living expenses. Roommates or housemates can split the cost of rent, utilities, and groceries, making it more cost-effective for everyone involved. Extended families may also benefit from shared expenses, but financial arrangements can be more complex, especially when multiple generations are involved and different family members have varying financial situations.

Community Involvement

Communal living arrangements often foster a sense of community among its members. Roommates or housemates may participate in group activities, share meals together, and support one another in times of need. Extended families also promote a sense of community, but it is centered around familial ties and traditions that have been passed down through generations.

Conclusion

Both communal living and extended families offer unique attributes and benefits to their members. Communal living provides a sense of community, shared resources, and flexibility in living arrangements. Extended families offer strong familial bonds, support systems, and a sense of tradition and heritage. Ultimately, the choice between communal living and extended families depends on individual preferences, values, and circumstances.