BS EN 10204 vs. EN 10204

Attribute	BS EN 10204	EN 10204
Standard	British Standard	European Standard
Scope	Specifies the different types of inspection documents required for metallic products	Specifies the technical delivery conditions for metallic products
Revision	Latest revision is BS EN 10204:2004	Latest revision is EN 10204:2004
Compliance	Compliance with BS EN 10204 is required for certain industries	Compliance with EN 10204 is required for certain industries

Introduction

BS EN 10204 and EN 10204 are both standards that provide guidelines for the inspection documents for metallic products. While they may seem similar due to their names, there are some key differences between the two that are important to understand. In this article, we will compare the attributes of BS EN 10204 and EN 10204 to help clarify any confusion and provide a better understanding of each standard.

Scope

BS EN 10204 is a British Standard that specifies the different types of inspection documents that can be provided to customers when metallic products are delivered. It outlines the various types of documents that can be used to demonstrate compliance with the specified requirements. On the other hand, EN 10204 is a European standard that also covers the inspection documents for metallic products, but it is applicable across all European countries. Both standards aim to ensure that customers receive the necessary documentation to verify the quality and conformity of the products they have purchased.

Types of Inspection Documents

One of the main differences between BS EN 10204 and EN 10204 is the types of inspection documents that are specified in each standard. BS EN 10204 outlines four different types of inspection documents: type 2.1, type 2.2, type 3.1, and type 3.2. Type 2.1 and type 2.2 documents are based on non-specific testing by the manufacturer, while type 3.1 and type 3.2 documents are based on specific testing and certification by an independent body. EN 10204, on the other hand, only specifies two types of inspection documents: type 2.1 and type 3.1. This difference in the number of specified document types is an important distinction between the two standards.

Acceptance Criteria

Another key difference between BS EN 10204 and EN 10204 is the acceptance criteria for the inspection documents. BS EN 10204 requires that the inspection documents must be in accordance with the order or contract and must provide evidence that the products meet the specified requirements. The standard also specifies that the documents must be signed by an authorized representative of the manufacturer. EN 10204, on the other hand, does not have specific requirements regarding the acceptance criteria for the inspection documents. This difference in acceptance criteria can impact how the documents are reviewed and accepted by customers.

Implementation

BS EN 10204 and EN 10204 are both widely used standards in the metal industry, but their implementation may vary depending on the country or region. BS EN 10204 is primarily used in the United Kingdom and other countries that follow British standards, while EN 10204 is used across all European countries. This difference in implementation can affect how manufacturers and customers interpret and apply the standards in their respective regions. It is important for companies to be aware of these differences to ensure compliance with the appropriate standard.

Conclusion

In conclusion, while BS EN 10204 and EN 10204 may seem similar due to their names, there are some key differences between the two standards. These include the types of inspection documents specified, acceptance criteria, and implementation. Understanding these differences is important for manufacturers and customers in the metal industry to ensure compliance with the appropriate standard and to facilitate the exchange of quality products. By comparing the attributes of BS EN 10204 and EN 10204, companies can make informed decisions about which standard to follow and how to best meet the requirements for inspection documents.