Bewitched vs. I Dream of Jeannie

What's the Difference?

Bewitched and I Dream of Jeannie are both classic sitcoms from the 1960s that center around magical beings living among mortals. In Bewitched, Samantha is a witch who marries a mortal man and tries to live a normal life, while in I Dream of Jeannie, Jeannie is a genie who falls in love with an astronaut and tries to grant his every wish. Both shows explore the comedic possibilities of having supernatural powers in a mundane world, but Bewitched focuses more on the challenges of fitting in and hiding one's true identity, while I Dream of Jeannie leans more towards the misadventures that arise from Jeannie's magical abilities.


AttributeBewitchedI Dream of Jeannie
Main CharacterSamantha StephensJeannie
SettingSuburban neighborhoodAstronaut's home
PlotWitch marries mortal and tries to live a normal lifeGenie falls in love with astronaut and tries to please him
Magical AbilitiesWitchcraftGenie powers
Love InterestDarrin StephensTony Nelson

Further Detail


Bewitched follows the story of Samantha Stephens, a witch who marries a mortal man named Darrin and tries to live a normal life without using her magical powers. The show focuses on the comedic situations that arise from Samantha's attempts to fit in with the mortal world while dealing with her magical family. On the other hand, I Dream of Jeannie revolves around an astronaut named Tony Nelson who discovers a genie named Jeannie and brings her home with him. The show explores the misadventures that occur as Tony tries to keep Jeannie's magical abilities a secret while navigating their unconventional relationship.

Main Characters

In Bewitched, Samantha Stephens is portrayed as a kind-hearted and loving wife who often finds herself in humorous situations due to her magical abilities. Her husband, Darrin Stephens, is a mortal advertising executive who struggles to accept Samantha's witchcraft and often finds himself at odds with her magical family. Other key characters include Samantha's mischievous mother Endora and her bumbling father Maurice. In I Dream of Jeannie, Tony Nelson is depicted as a charming and resourceful astronaut who tries to balance his career with Jeannie's magical antics. Jeannie is a beautiful and impulsive genie who is deeply in love with Tony and constantly tries to use her powers to help him, often with unintended consequences.


Bewitched is set in the suburbs of Westport, Connecticut, where Samantha and Darrin live in a typical suburban neighborhood. The show often features scenes in the Stephens' home, as well as other locations such as Darrin's advertising agency and the magical realm of Samantha's family. In contrast, I Dream of Jeannie takes place in Cocoa Beach, Florida, where Tony and Jeannie reside in a beachfront home. The show frequently showcases the tropical setting of Cocoa Beach, as well as Tony's workplace at NASA and various other locations where Jeannie's magic causes chaos.

Tone and Humor

Bewitched is known for its light-hearted and whimsical tone, with a focus on the comedic misunderstandings that arise from Samantha's attempts to live a normal life. The show often uses clever wordplay and situational humor to create laughs, as well as the physical comedy of Samantha's magical mishaps. On the other hand, I Dream of Jeannie has a more slapstick and farcical humor, with Jeannie's magical powers leading to exaggerated and over-the-top situations. The show also features a romantic subplot between Tony and Jeannie, adding a different dynamic to the humor compared to Bewitched.

Legacy and Impact

Both Bewitched and I Dream of Jeannie have left a lasting impact on popular culture, with their unique premises and memorable characters becoming iconic in the world of television. Bewitched is often praised for its feminist undertones and portrayal of a strong female lead, while I Dream of Jeannie is celebrated for its fantastical elements and romantic storyline. Both shows have been referenced and parodied in various forms of media over the years, solidifying their places in television history.

Comparisons may contain inaccurate information about people, places, or facts. Please report any issues.