Arthur Morgan vs. John Marston

Attribute	Arthur Morgan	John Marston
Protagonist in Red Dead Redemption 2	Yes	No
Gang member	Yes	Yes
Outlaw	Yes	Yes
Family man	No	Yes
Redemption arc	Yes	Yes

Background

Arthur Morgan and John Marston are two of the most iconic characters in the Red Dead Redemption series. Both characters are outlaws who are part of the Van der Linde gang, but they have distinct personalities and attributes that set them apart from each other.

Physical Appearance

Arthur Morgan is a rugged and imposing figure, with a tall and muscular build. He has a weathered face with a prominent scar on his left cheek, and his hair is typically styled in a messy, unkempt manner. In contrast, John Marston is leaner and more agile, with a more youthful appearance. He has a clean-shaven face and shorter hair, giving him a more polished look compared to Arthur.

Personality

Arthur Morgan is known for his loyalty and sense of duty towards the gang, often putting the needs of others before his own. He is a complex character who struggles with his own morality and the violent nature of his lifestyle. John Marston, on the other hand, is more straightforward and pragmatic. He is driven by a desire to leave his outlaw past behind and build a better life for himself and his family.

Skills and Abilities

Arthur Morgan is a skilled gunslinger and tracker, known for his proficiency with a variety of weapons. He is also a capable horse rider and can handle himself in hand-to-hand combat. John Marston, on the other hand, is a master marksman with a quick draw and deadly accuracy. He is also skilled in hunting and tracking, making him a valuable asset in the wilderness.

Relationships

Arthur Morgan has deep connections with the members of the Van der Linde gang, particularly with Dutch van der Linde, the gang's leader. He acts as a mentor and father figure to younger members like Jack Marston and is respected by his peers for his leadership skills. John Marston, on the other hand, has a more strained relationship with the gang, often questioning Dutch's leadership and motives. He is fiercely protective of his family and will do whatever it takes to keep them safe.

Motivations

Arthur Morgan is motivated by a sense of duty and loyalty to the gang, as well as a desire to find redemption for his past sins. He struggles with his own morality and the violent nature of his lifestyle, constantly questioning his actions and their consequences. John Marston, on the other hand, is motivated by a desire to leave his outlaw past behind and start anew with his family. He is willing to do whatever it takes to ensure their safety and security.

Character Development

Throughout the course of the Red Dead Redemption series, both Arthur Morgan and John Marston undergo significant character development. Arthur starts off as a loyal enforcer for the gang but begins to question his loyalty as he sees the true nature of Dutch's plans. He ultimately chooses to break away from the gang and seek redemption for his past actions. John, on the other hand, starts off as a reluctant outlaw who is forced to confront his past when the government threatens his family. He ultimately sacrifices himself to ensure their safety and redemption.

Conclusion

Arthur Morgan and John Marston are two of the most memorable characters in the Red Dead Redemption series, each with their own unique attributes and personalities. While Arthur is known for his loyalty and sense of duty, John is driven by a desire to leave his outlaw past behind and build a better life for his family. Both characters undergo significant development throughout the series, making them complex and compelling protagonists in the world of Red Dead Redemption.